If you’re seeking bar admission, chances are you’ll need to take the Multistate Professional Responsibility Examination (MPRE). Passing the MPRE is required in most jurisdictions, and the exam primarily tests the American Bar Association’s Model Rules of Professional Conduct.
On the MPRE, about 6 to 12 percent of questions focus on competence, malpractice, and civil liability. That means you can expect several questions on these topics. A common scenario involves lawyers attempting to limit their liability for malpractice by asking clients to sign releases. Whether that is allowed is governed by Model Rule 1.8(h).
Limiting Liability for Malpractice Under Model Rule 1.8(h)
A lawyer may attempt to limit malpractice liability, but the rules impose strict limitations. Understanding the difference between prospective waivers and settlement of claims is key for the MPRE.
Prospectively Limiting Malpractice Claims
Lawyers may want to include provisions in engagement agreements that limit future malpractice liability. However, this is generally not permitted. Under Model Rule 1.8(h), a lawyer cannot prospectively limit liability for malpractice unless the client is independently represented in making that agreement.
This requirement is strictly enforced and frequently tested. If the client does not have independent counsel, the agreement is improper.
Settling Malpractice Claims
The rules are slightly different when a malpractice claim already exists or is being considered. A lawyer may settle a claim with a client or former client, but only if specific safeguards are followed.
The lawyer must advise the client in writing to seek independent legal counsel and must give the client a reasonable opportunity to do so. Without these steps, the settlement is improper.
How This Appears on the MPRE
MPRE questions in this area often include distracting details. Answer choices may focus on contract law concepts like consideration or whether a fee is reasonable. These are not the key issues.
Instead, the correct answer will turn on whether the lawyer followed the required procedures. For prospective limitations, the client must have independent representation. For settlements, the lawyer must provide written notice advising the client to seek independent counsel.
Final Thoughts
This is a highly testable area of professional responsibility. The rules are strict, and small details can determine whether an answer is correct. Memorizing the procedural requirements and recognizing common traps will help you pick up points on exam day.
Prepare with BARBRI MPRE Review to fully understand Model Rule 1.8(h) and other frequently tested ethics rules so you can identify the correct answer quickly and confidently on exam day.
Interested in reading more? Fill out the form to read the full article.