Primary v. Excess Insurance: Vertical and Horizontal Exhaustion of Policy Limits Priority and Allocation of Coverage
Analyzing the Effect of California Supreme Court's Adoption of Vertical Exhaustion in Montrose Chemical

Course Details
- smart_display Format
On-Demand
- signal_cellular_alt Difficulty Level
- work Practice Area
Insurance
- event Date
Wednesday, July 29, 2020
- schedule Time
1:00 p.m. ET./10:00 a.m. PT
- timer Program Length
90 minutes
-
This 90-minute webinar is eligible in most states for 1.5 CLE credits.
This CLE course will explore the nationwide impact of a unanimous decision in favor of corporate policyholders by the California Supreme Court in April 2020. Policyholders can identify which policy years have the best coverage, collect, and let the carriers resolve further allocation. Any business with successive years of multi-layered policies to cover potential "long-tail" liabilities will benefit.
Faculty

Exclusively representing policyholders, Ms. Waters focuses her practice on complex insurance litigation matters with a special focus on power, oil and energy. Since joining the firm, she has dedicated her time to a number of complex builder’s risk insurance coverage disputes on large construction projects and central utility plants across the country. Ms. Waters has also worked on professional liability coverage disputes associated with design-build projects relating to propane dehydrogenation and hydrocracking plants located in the Middle East.

Mr. Raskin is head of the firm’s Insurance Recovery Practice in the San Francisco office. He has represented clients involved in litigation, arbitration and mediation in matters related to insurance coverage, environmental disputes, and IP disputes, among others. Mr. Raskin has handled insurance matters seeking recovery for catastrophic losses in environmental, asbestos, silica, toxic tort, product liability, and securities cases.
Description
Resolving when and in what order a policyholder may access primary and excess insurance coverage is always challenging. This is particularly true when there are multiple-years of layered primary and excess policies to cover claims made or settled long after the insurance policy expired. Many policies attempt to specify the order of coverage access and often make benefits available only after "other insurance" has been exhausted.
In Montrose Chemical Corp. v. The Superior Ct. of Los Angeles Cty, the court held that “other insurance” clauses do not clearly specify whether a rule of horizontal or vertical exhaustion and that the analysis is governed instead by other policy provisions, such as those addressing the attachment of liability and information contained within the schedules of underlying insurance in the excess policies. Policyholders can identify which policy years have the best coverage, collect, and leave the carriers to resolve further allocation among themselves.
Nonetheless, carriers may still hold a great deal of power by refusing to settle until after concluding allocation matters.
Listen as our authoritative panel discusses this ruling, how policyholders benefit, and why the impact of this decision is not limited to California jurisdictions.
Outline
- Overview of primary and excess policies
- How vertical and horizontal exhaustion of policy limits differ
- The role of excess coverage for "long-tail" claims involving continuous or progressive injuries
- The impact of the California ruling in Montrose Chemical on future claims
Benefits
The panel will review these and other contentious issues:
- The interplay between primary and excess insurance
- Excess, multi-year coverage in the context of latent or "long-tail" injury
- How policyholders can use vertical exhaustion to maximize coverage and benefits
Unlimited access to premium CLE courses:
- Annual access
- Available live and on-demand
- Best for attorneys and legal professionals
Unlimited access to premium CPE courses.:
- Annual access
- Available live and on-demand
- Best for CPAs and tax professionals
Unlimited access to premium CLE, CPE, Professional Skills and Practice-Ready courses.:
- Annual access
- Available live and on-demand
- Best for legal, accounting, and tax professionals
Related Courses

Insurance Carrier Intervention in Underlying Tort Cases: Options for Preserving Coverage-Related Facts
Thursday, May 29, 2025
1:00 p.m. ET./10:00 a.m. PT

Foreign Tortfeasors and Subrogation: Why Typical Approaches Fail; Alternative Negotiation Strategies
Tuesday, April 1, 2025
1:00 p.m. ET./10:00 a.m. PT

Insurance Bad Faith Litigation: Strategies and Practical Tools to Successfully Resist Entry of Protective Orders
Friday, April 25, 2025
1:00 p.m. ET./10:00 a.m. PT
Recommended Resources
Navigating Modern Legal Challenges: A Comprehensive Guide
- Business & Professional Skills
- Career Advancement
Your Guide to Professional Development with BARBRI
- Learning & Development
- Business & Professional Skills
- Career Advancement
- eDiscovery
Building Your Book: Strategies to Secure Long-Term Success
- Business & Professional Skills
- Career Advancement
- Talent Development