• videocam On-Demand Webinar
  • signal_cellular_alt Intermediate
  • card_travel Litigation
  • schedule 90 minutes

Mallory v. Norfolk Southern: Due Process and Requiring Out-of-State Firms to Consent to Personal Jurisdiction

Ensuring Equal Treatment for Individuals and Fictitious Corporate Persons

About the Course

Introduction

This CLE course will discuss the ramifications of Mallory v. Norfolk Southern Railway Co., __ U.S. __ (June 27, 2023), and its application to other cases. The panel will analyze the Court's reasoning, the issues raised in Justice Alito's opinion concurring in part and in the judgment, and the arguments of the dissent to help counsel for both plaintiffs and defendants assess the decision’s consequences for personal jurisdiction.

Description

In Mallory, the Court held that the Due Process Clause of the Fourteenth Amendment does not prohibit a state from requiring out-of-state corporations to consent to personal jurisdiction to do business there. Justice Alito (concurring in the judgment) even wrote (in dicta) that nothing in the Due Process Clause prohibits forum shopping--by corporate or individual plaintiffs.

The dissent contends the holding is a sea change in the Court's personal jurisdiction jurisprudence and that the Due Process Clause permits only two types of personal jurisdiction over a corporate defendant.

According to Justice Alito, however, the federalism concerns in consent-by-registration laws as broad as Pennsylvania's are better analyzed under the dormant Commerce Clause than under the Due Process Clause. Whether these statutes survive such a dormant Commerce Clause test and whether that line of inquiry will yield more certainty or less forum shopping is yet to be seen.

Listen as this experienced panel discusses the ramifications and responses to Mallory and considers how litigants might argue for or against jurisdiction and whether broad jurisdiction-by-consent statutes may not pass muster under the dormant Commerce Clause.

Presented By

Bennett Evan Cooper
Member and Appeals and Advocacy Practice Group Co-Chair
Dickinson Wright PLLC

Mr. Cooper advocates for clients in high stakes appeals and writ proceedings in the U.S. Supreme Court, federal circuit courts, and state supreme and intermediate appellate courts from coast to coast. His practice includes appeals in a broad range of subject matter, with particular emphasis on such fields as insurance coverage and bad-faith defense; intellectual-property protection and e-commerce disputes; professional liability; federal, state, and local taxation; Native American law; and constitutional litigation. In March 2023, Mr. Cooper argued before the U.S. Supreme Court in Jack Daniel’s Properties, Inc. v. VIP Products LLC, a landmark case involving trademark parodies, and prevailed on remand in light of the Supreme Court’s new standards for infringement claims against parodies. In the U.S. Court of Appeals for the Ninth Circuit, he is the author of Thomson Reuters’s 1,000-page treatise Federal Appellate Practice: Ninth Circuit. A current member of the Ninth Circuit’s Advisory Committee on Rules of Practice and Internal Operating Procedures, Mr. Cooper previously served as the court-appointed Chair of the Appellate Lawyer Representatives to the Ninth Circuit Judicial Conference.

Christopher S. Dodrill
Shareholder
Greenberg Traurig LLP

Mr. Dodrill counsels and represents corporate and individual clients in federal and state courts in Texas and other jurisdictions across the country. He has a diverse litigation practice that includes complex commercial disputes, business torts, financial services litigation, data privacy actions, legal malpractice defense, and internal investigations. Mr. Dodrill has significant experience in multi-district litigation and class action defense.

Thomas J. Sullivan
Partner
Shook Hardy & Bacon

Mr. Sullivan's litigation practice focuses on high-profile, complex commercial litigation and tort litigation, including class actions, multi-district litigation, and other aggregate litigation throughout the United States. He has extensive experience in complex civil litigation across a variety of industries, practice areas, and geographies, and he has particularly deep experience defending class actions, commercial disputes in the life sciences and health care industries, and in toxic and mass tort litigation. Mr. Sullivan has represented companies in matters involving complex financial issues, construction and building materials, automobiles, pharmaceuticals, third-party payors, ERISA, RICO, supply and distribution issues, food and beverage labeling, and various consumer products and contracts. Many of these matters have been litigated against the backdrop of criminal and/or regulatory enforcement efforts. He has played a lead role at trials in state and federal court in which he has examined fact and expert witnesses, and he has argued appeals. Mr. Sullivan also has extensive arbitration experience. He also maintains an active pro bono practice committed to litigating issues of systemic justice.

Credit Information
  • This 90-minute webinar is eligible in most states for 1.5 CLE credits.


  • Live Online


    On Demand

Date + Time

  • event

    Tuesday, August 29, 2023

  • schedule

    1:00 p.m. ET./10:00 a.m. PT

  1. Jurisdiction by consent statutes overview
  2. Review of Mallory decision
    1. Plurality opinion
    2. Justice Alito's opinion concurring in part and in the judgment
    3. Dissent
  3. Strategies for plaintiffs
  4. Strategies for defendants

The panel will consider these and other key issues:

  • Would a contrary result in Mallory have given an out-of-state company more rights and privileges and fewer liabilities, restrictions, duties, and penalties than those imposed on domestic entities?
  • Why was the Court concerned with the potential disparate treatment of the hypothetical conductor and Norfolk Southern?
  • Did Mallory substantially broaden the bases for general personal jurisdiction over out-of-state corporations for claims brought by out-of-state plaintiffs or simply change the battlefield?