Description
With a thorough understanding of how the applicable jurisdiction apportions fault, plaintiff’s counsel can nimbly thwart attempts to inappropriately shift blame and focus from the defendant to plaintiff.
It is black letter law that defendants must take their plaintiffs as they find them, but too often the defense tries to suggest that preexisting conditions should preclude pain and suffering compensation for the "eggshell" plaintiff. Nothing could be further from the truth.
Preexisting injury cases require thoughtful planning and often the use of experts, but preexisting conditions can justify higher damages by explaining that the extent and severity of the plaintiff's pain and suffering under circumstances in which others might not have been hurt.
Listen as this experienced panel guides counsel through the advantages and disadvantages of taking cases involving preexisting injuries as well as how to navigate allegations of comparative and contributory fault.
Presented By
Ms. Ptacek is a lawyer in the firm’s Personal Injury Section, where she represents individuals who have been injured and family members of deceased victims. Before joining the firm, she worked for a different plaintiff’s firm in Georgia, handling cases involving catastrophic injury, premises liability, trucking accidents, amputation, medical malpractice, wrongful death, whistleblower / qui tam, government monitorship and federal criminal defense. Prior to law school, Ms. Ptacek worked as a paralegal in a solo practice firm handling car accidents, trucking accidents, and premises liability cases.
Mr. Seiferheld has been a trial lawyer for nearly 25 years. He specializes in litigation involving large commercial vehicles and semi-trucks, No-Fault matters, insurance coverage disputes, municipal vehicles and construction accidents. Mr. Seiferheld has argued complex legal issues before the Michigan Court of Appeals on several occasions and achieved victories for his clients every time. He has obtained millions of dollars for his injured clients and is a tenacious fighter both inside and out of the courtroom.
-
This 90-minute webinar is eligible in most states for 1.5 CLE credits.
-
Date + Time
- event
Thursday, July 13, 2023
- schedule
1:00 p.m. ET./10:00 a.m. PT
- Comparative and contributory fault schemes
- Factors that impact juries' apportionment of fault
- Best practices for personal injury attorneys to overcome plaintiff's level of fault
- Types of preexisting condition
- Asymptomatic
- Symptomatic preexisting condition that is worsened
- Overall physicality is diminished
- Physical and mental preexisting conditions
- Causation
- Different injury
- Aggravated injury
- Factors supporting general damages related to preexisting conditions
- Personality and demeanor of plaintiff
- Location, timing, nature of post-accident pain and suffering
- Role of experts
- Before and after activities
- Transparency
- Jury instructions
The panel will review these and other key issues:
- What is the effect of a plaintiff's partial responsibility for an accident?
- What arguments work best for reducing the plaintiff's fault?
- How might preexisting conditions increase recovery for pain and suffering compared to cases with none?
- What factors affect recovery in preexisting condition cases?
- Does it matter if the preexisting condition is emotional, mental, or physical?
Related Courses
Motor Vehicle and Premises Liability Complexities Resulting From Low-Light Conditions
Wednesday, October 29, 2025
1:00 p.m. ET./10:00 a.m. PT