Thank you!
The full article is available below.
You will also receive a follow-up email containing a link so you can come back to it later.
It’s a familiar scene: a junior lawyer spends ages drafting a ‘perfect’ but ultimately unhelpful legal memo. The supervising lawyer is busy and doesn’t have the bandwidth to sit down and explain what’s missing, beyond: “it’s not commercial enough.” The junior is deflated, the already busy supervisor now adds another task to their list, and the problem is likely to repeat. The issue isn’t just the quality of the memo, it’s that we expect junior lawyers to have an important professional skill without ever making it explicit.
In our conversations with senior lawyers, partners, general counsel, heads of departments and legal teams, “commercial awareness” comes up as one of the knottiest topics for junior lawyers. Remote working and ongoing AI adoption have compounded the problem by reducing much of the “overheard” context — the on-the-job learning gained from watching, listening and role-modelling. If junior lawyers can’t naturally absorb this professional skill, then we need to focus on more deliberate ways of developing it.
What Commercial Means
It’s not so much that junior lawyers don’t know what “being commercial” means; it’s that they don’t know how to go about demonstrating it at work.
It helps to separate two ideas: commercial awareness and commercial mindset. Commercial awareness, often tested at interview, is knowing what is happening in the business news and markets. A commercial mindset is applying that understanding to live matters, contextualising it and thinking through what a sensible approach might look like.
Reading the financial press is a great start, but useful only if the junior lawyer can translate that information into implications. An interest-rate decision, profit warning or regulatory change matters not because it’s newsworthy, but because it may affect the client’s financing, appetite for risk, negotiating position, timetable or need for legal support.
The reality is that junior lawyers are often commercially aware and yet still produce work that is insufficiently ‘commercial’.
It’s a Skill, Not a Character Trait
A commercial mindset can look like a natural talent, but those who seem most adept have usually grown up in an environment where business and markets were discussed. It is a skill built through exposure and developed through practice and feedback. It starts by asking better questions:
- What is the client actually trying to accomplish?
- What external forces are changing the client’s priorities?
- What does a financial headline mean for the client rather than for an investor?
- What are the client’s strengths, vulnerabilities and strategic priorities?
- How does the firm’s own strategy intersect with the work?
Four Principles in Practice
Those questions are where the thinking begins. The four principles below are how it shows up in everyday work and they are usually what supervisors mean, but rarely spell out, when they ask for something “more commercial”. Junior lawyers can develop each one through small, consistent steps.
- Understand the client’s business. You can’t give good advice if you don’t know what the client does and its industry position. That means reading up about the client: its website, recent news, and annual reports (if available). You need to understand how it makes money, and who it competes with. It's what makes advice and risk calibration meaningful.
- Treat risk as a spectrum. Clients don’t want to hear “no” but equally they don’t want risks ignored. Commercially astute lawyers identify the risk, evaluate its seriousness and suggest options to reduce or otherwise deal with it.
- Judge what’s proportionate. Not every issue is worth fighting over. It’s neither professional nor good business to ‘over-lawyer’ a low-value contract. Clients are sensitive to budgets and deadlines, so a good commercial lawyer needs to be so too.
- Lead with the answer. Good writing starts with what you think, your opinion or your advice, and then segues to why, and what you need from the reader. Attention spans are stretched. Neither clients nor supervisors have time for two pages of analysis and the answer on page three. Sometimes being commercial is as simple as making sure your message is clear first, and well substantiated second.
Spell Out What’s Rarely Said
Firms devote enormous resource to teaching legal skills, systems and processes. Moving from understanding the legal problem to understanding the client’s business problem is a separate developmental step and one that also needs to be taught explicitly. Telling junior lawyers to “be more commercial” is not enough to change behaviour. Firms need to make the underlying thinking visible. First, model the questions experienced lawyers ask, secondly explain the commercial context surrounding assignments, and third give junior lawyers opportunities to apply that thinking and receive feedback.
Formal training has a clear role here, provided it supplements rather than replaces live work. A workshop on commercial awareness won’t build a commercial mindset on its own; the lessons must be applied to real matters for the skill to properly develop. What formal training can excel at is providing the information and tools from which to build. It can succinctly cover how law firms make money, explain how to develop business strategy and what to look for in business news and markets and then how to apply that knowledge. This foundation is then best reinforced by live learning, from shadowing calls and negotiations, to attending deal-briefs led by senior lawyers and secondments to client organisations.
Building the Foundation
Structured learning can help build the foundation for commercially astute lawyers. Our Work Ready for New Associates series, now includes modules such as Making Sense of Financial News and Relationships Are Revenue, designed to build a commercial mindset. We can teach our junior lawyers to be ‘more commercial’ but only if we acknowledge it’s not something they will simply pick up in the short term — we need to be intentional about helping them.
Unlock the Full Article
Bring Your Goals Within ReachTell us a little about yourself and your goals to display the full article and gain access to more resources relevant to your needs.
Interested in reading more? Fill out the form to read the full article.