- videocam Live Webinar with Live Q&A
- calendar_month December 1, 2026 @ 1:00 PM ET/10:00 AM PT
- signal_cellular_alt Intermediate
- card_travel Litigation
- schedule 90 minutes
Appellate Persuasion Using Non-Binding Authority: Citing and Responding to Unpublished Opinions, Dissents, Dicta
Welcome to BARBRI, the trusted global leader in legal education. Continue to access the same expert-led Strafford CLE and CPE webinars you know and value. Plus, explore professional skills courses and more.
About the Course
Introduction
This CLE webinar will discuss guidance and key considerations for citing and responding to unpublished opinions in federal appeals, identifying and handling dicta, leveraging dissents, and grounding any non-binding authority in established principles of law.
Description
Most appellate decisions are unpublished opinions that are not binding precedent. The same is true of dicta. In reality, however, non-binding decisions, dissents, or concurrences—and even dicta—have an enormous influence on how cases get decided and how the law develops. Dicta can even get elevated to holding.
Unreported opinions decide actual controversies and may be the only authority on a recurring issue. The Supreme Court grants certiorari to unpublished decisions all the time. But even experienced counsel often debate how much weight to give them, and when to ask a court to publish an opinion.
Appellate lawyers face an analogous conundrum with dicta. Dicta can be difficult to define, and every "test" for what it is or is not comes up short. Recognizing dicta can be particularly important when cases may have to be appealed multiple times. Stare decisis depends on it. Binding or not, dicta can offer additional insights into a court's logic and can be extremely persuasive—and telling a court that what it said can just be ignored is not always the wisest strategy.
Listen as this esteemed panel offers guidance to appellate lawyers on citing and leveraging technically non-binding opinions and portions of opinions to achieve their clients' goals.
Presented By
Mr. Cooper advocates for clients in high stakes appeals and writ proceedings in the U.S. Supreme Court, federal circuit courts, and state supreme and intermediate appellate courts from coast to coast. His practice includes appeals in a broad range of subject matter, with particular emphasis on such fields as insurance coverage and bad-faith defense; intellectual-property protection and e-commerce disputes; professional liability; federal, state, and local taxation; Native American law; and constitutional litigation. In March 2023, Mr. Cooper argued before the U.S. Supreme Court in Jack Daniel’s Properties, Inc. v. VIP Products LLC, a landmark case involving trademark parodies, and prevailed on remand in light of the Supreme Court’s new standards for infringement claims against parodies. In the U.S. Court of Appeals for the Ninth Circuit, he is the author of Thomson Reuters’s 1,000-page treatise Federal Appellate Practice: Ninth Circuit. A current member of the Ninth Circuit’s Advisory Committee on Rules of Practice and Internal Operating Procedures, Mr. Cooper previously served as the court-appointed Chair of the Appellate Lawyer Representatives to the Ninth Circuit Judicial Conference.
During three decades as a litigator, Mr. Gant has built a diverse practice with particular focus and deep experience in complex commercial litigation, class actions, antitrust, and constitutional law. He represents plaintiffs and defendants, at both the trial and appellate levels (including before the U.S. Supreme Court). Mr. Gant has taught a constitutional law seminar at Georgetown Law School as an adjunct professor and actively writes on a range of legal issues. In addition to his scholarly articles published in law reviews, Mr. Gant's opinion pieces have appeared in The Wall Street Journal, Washington Post, Los Angeles Times, Christian Science Monitor, Forbes, Huffington Post, Salon, and Wired. His book, We're All Journalists Now: The Transformation of the Press and Reshaping of the Law in the Internet Age, was published by Simon & Schuster’s Free Press. Mr. Gant has also arbitrated attorney-client fee disputes for more than two decades for the District of Columbia Bar’s Attorney/Client Arbitration Board. He is also co-leader of the Class Actions practice group.
Mr. Roach has practiced civil trial and appellate law since 1981 — 44 years spanning products liability defense, medical malpractice defense, insurance coverage, and appellate work at both the intermediate court and Texas Supreme Court levels. He was Board Certified in Personal Injury Trial Law and elected to membership in ABOTA before the firm's appellate practice became the center of gravity of his career. Mr. Roach founded Roach Newton in 1993. On argued merits, the firm's Texas Supreme Court practice has won more than four times as often as it has lost, alongside a substantial record of persuading the Court not to take review in matters where the firm represented the respondent. He holds three board certifications, a Fellowship in the American Academy of Appellate Lawyers, and received his undergraduate degree from Georgetown University and his law degree from the University of Texas School of Law, where he served on the Texas Law Review and won the Hildebrand Moot Court Championship. Mr. Roach taught Texas Supreme Court brief writing and oral argument alongside sitting judges and staff attorneys at the University of Houston Law Center (1990–2022) and the University of Texas School of Law (2000–2023) — more than fifty semesters, in courses he created for those institutions. He has presented more than 180 CLE papers since 1989.
-
This 90-minute webinar is eligible in most states for 1.5 CLE credits.
-
Live Online
On Demand
Date + Time
- event
Tuesday, December 1, 2026
- schedule
1:00 PM ET/10:00 AM PT
I. What makes non-binding judicial decisions persuasive
A. Unpublished decisions
B. Concurrences and dissents
C. Dicta
D. Out-of-system decisions
E. Secondary authorities
II. Relevant rules
A. Fed. R. App. P. 32.1
B. State rules: how state practice differs from the federal model
III. Best practices
A. Citing and responding to unpublished decisions
B. Citing and responding to concurrences and dissents opinions
C. Citing and responding to dicta
D. Citing and responding to out-of-system decisions
E. Citing and responding to secondary authority
IV. Consequences of mishandling non-binding authority
A. With the court
B. Reputationally
The panel will offer guidance on these and other significant questions:
- What makes non-binding judicial decisions persuasive?
- What are the pros and cons of labeling opinions "non-precedential" or "not for publication," and how did Federal Rule of Appellate Procedure 32.1 moderate the debate?
- If the only law on an issue is found in a body of unpublished decisions, are they really non-binding if judges follow them?
- Why is it so important to be able to distinguish dicta, and what are practical ways to identify it?
- How can lawyers argue that part of an opinion is dicta without appearing disrespectful?
- May or should lawyers or law firms argue in one matter that certain text is dicta and then argue in another matter that the same text on the same issue is part of the court's reasoning and therefore binding?
- How might a court's dissent be used to shape future strategy?
Unlimited access to premium CLE courses:
- Annual access
- Available live and on-demand
- Best for attorneys and legal professionals
Unlimited access to premium CPE courses.:
- Annual access
- Available live and on-demand
- Best for CPAs and tax professionals
Unlimited access to premium CLE, CPE, Professional Skills and Practice-Ready courses.:
- Annual access
- Available live and on-demand
- Best for legal, accounting, and tax professionals
Unlimited access to Professional Skills and Practice-Ready courses:
- Annual access
- Available on-demand
- Best for new attorneys
Related Courses
Appellate Persuasion Using Non-Binding Authority: Citing and Responding to Unpublished Opinions, Dissents, Dicta
Tuesday, December 1, 2026
1:00 PM ET/10:00 AM PT
Recommended Resources
How Venable Tailors Professional Essentials to Each Stage of Associate Development
- Business & Professional Skills