BarbriSFCourseDetails

Course Details

This CLE course will discuss the best removal and remand strategies for getting a case into or keeping a case in a preferred forum or moving it out of an opponent's choice of forum. The program will cover the forum defendant rule, snap removal, 28 U.S.C. 1147(e), 28 U.S.C. 1446, federal officer removal, federal question jurisdiction, and the consequences of removal on pleadings and motion practice. The panel will also point out how to spot what the opposing party may be up to and the best responses for countermoves.

Faculty

Description

A defendant in a lawsuit filed in state court can "remove" the case to federal court if there is a diversity of citizenship, except if a "properly joined and served" defendant is a citizen of the forum state. With the advent of electronic filing, defendants now have instantaneous notice of suits and may remove the case before being served, thereby sidestepping the forum defendant rule. Although several U.S. Circuit Courts have approved the practice, a debate remains on whether this practice should be approved.

Plaintiffs have their own toolbox to anticipate removal strategies and take preemptive actions to make removal difficult and remand likely. Since all parties can play the literal-reading-of-the-statute card, plaintiffs have seized on ways to bring the "real" parties into the dispute in such a way as to prevent removal.

If the case comes to a stop in federal court after removal, the parties must be aware of how the change in forum impacts the rest of the case: deadlines, motions, pleadings, what must be answered, and what is stayed.

Listen as this experienced panel of litigators discusses which removal and remand planning and strategies can make the most difference.

Outline

  1. Removal
    1. Removal Basics
      1. When, where, and how?
    2. Diversity jurisdiction
      1. Citizenship
      2. Amount in Controversy
      3. CAFA (briefly)
    3. Federal question jurisdiction
      1. What counts?
      2. Unique Circumstances
    4. Timing
      1. When the clock starts
      2. “Snap” removal
    5. Defensive considerations
  2. Remand
    1. Motions to Remand
      1. Timeliness, general procedure
    2. Waiving Remand
    3. Opposing a Motion to Remand
      1. General procedure
      2. Arguments to Make
    4. Removal After Remand
      1. Second notice of removal
      2. Evidence of Plaintiff's Bad Faith?

Benefits

The panel will review these and other key issues:

  • What statutes govern removal and remand?
  • What is snap removal?
  • What is federal officer removal, and when does it apply?
  • How can one avoid pleading with federal issues or questions?
  • What are the consequences of successful removal?
  • Can removal or remand occur well past the 30-day time period in 28 U.S.C. 1441?